Polizzi's

274 North Goodman St, Rochester NY 14607

$$ Mediterranean Top 10 Recommended New Editor's Pick Private Room Outdoor Seating

We are a casual fine dining restaurant serving Italian, Greek, Spanish, and French cuisine. We are located at the Village Gate in the heart of Rochester's Neighborhood of the Arts District. Our mission is to not only please your palate but to provide you with an enjoyable overall dining experience as well. It would be our honor to have you as our guest. Thank you, Tom & Debbie Polizzi and our staff!

Reservations

Polizzi's Reservations

585-363-5100

Date

Time

Party Size

Business Info

Address: 274 North Goodman St, Rochester NY 14607
Cross Street: Between University and Main
Cuisine: French | Greek | Italian | Mediterranean | Spanish |
Cost: | Inexpensive
Category: Casual Dining
Star Rating:
Reservations: Recommended
Dress Code: Casual
Meals Served: Dinner |
Parking: Car Park |
Payment Options: VISA | Amex | MasterCard | Discover | Cash |
Corkage Fee: 15.00 | Tuesday Nights No Corkage Fee
Website: www.polizzis.com
Phone: 585-363-5100
Features: Full Bar, Catering Services, Outdoor Seating, Takeout Available, Wheelchair Access, Happy Hours,
Occasion: Child Friendly, Romantic Dining, Dining Alone, Business Dining, Meet for a Drink, Quiet Conversation, Special Occasion, Vegetarian, Dog Friendly, Quick Bite, Date Night,

Photos

Business Hours

Reservations Available

Monday: Bar 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM; Main Dining Room 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday: Bar 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM; Main Dining Room 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday: Bar 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM; Main Dining Room 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Thursday: Bar 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM; Main Dining Room 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Friday: Dining at the bar 4:30 PM - 10:00 PM; Main Dining Room 4:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday: Dining at the bar 4:30 PM - 10:00 PM; Main Dining Room 4:30 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday: Closed

F.A.Q.s

Frequently Asked Questions

Where are you located?: We are inside the Village Gate in the space formally occupied by the Gate House Restaurant @ 274 N.Goodman Street
Are reservations required?: No, but are helpful.
Do you have outdoor dining?: Yes! We have 9 tables available on our partially covered patio area off our main dining room
Do you offer gluten free items?: Yes we have many gluten free options. Please see our menu on our website.

Menus

Dinner Menu

Appitizers

SOUP DuJour 4.00: Cup
SOUP DuJour 8.00: Bowl
VEGETARIAN MEATBALLS 11.00: ROASTED EGGPLANT, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, SUN DRIED TOMATO PESTO, GARLIC, BASIL, BREAD CRUMBS, PARMESAN & FETA CHEESES over MARINARA SAUCE
SHRIMP AJILLO (GF) 15.00: 3 SHRIMP SAUTEÉD IN OLIVE OIL w/ GARLIC, COGNAC, SMOKED PAPRIKA & LEMON over SAUTEÉD SPINACH
GRANDMA CARMELLA’S MINULOTTI 13.00: WOOD FIRED OVEN BAKED ITALIAN SAUSAGE STUFFED BREAD TOPPED w/ MELTED FRESH MOZZARELLA CHEESE MARINARA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
TRAMEZZINO 9.00: WOOD FIRED OVEN BAKED HOUSE MADE ROSEMARY FOCACCIA SANDWICH w/SUNDRIED TOMATO PESTO, BASIL PESTO, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, ARTICHOKE HEARTS & 12 MONTH AGED MANCHEGO CHEESE
GREEK COMBO PLATTER (FOR 2) 16.00: 4 SPANAKOPITA, 2 DOLMADES, TZATZIKI, KALAMATA OLIVES, FETA CHEESE & GRILLED PITA BREAD
CALAMARI FRITO 17.00: LIGHTLY FRIED FRESH SQUID w/ LEMON GARLIC-AIOLI & MARINARA SAUCE
GREEK STYLE CALAMARI 20.00: LIGHTLY FRIED FRESH SQUID with KALAMATA OLIVES, PEPPERONCINI, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, GARLIC, FETA CHEESE, LEMON & WHITE WINE
BURRATA 18.00: SOFT CREAMY CENTERED FRESH MOZZARELLA w/ DRIED FIGS, CURED MEATS, BALSAMIC GLAZE & GRILLED GARLIC CRUSTINI
SAGANAKI (FLAMING CHEESE) 12.00: BREADED MELTED KASSERI CHEESE FLAMBÉ w/ GRILLED PITA BREAD
HOUSE MADE SAUSAGE SAMPLER 17.00: HOUSE MADE BLUEBERRY – CHIPOLTE & WINE – CHEESE - PARSLEY SAUSAGES GRILLED w/DIJON MUSTARD, OLIVES, CORNICHONE PICKLES, GARLIC MARINATED ROASTED RED PEPPERS & GRILLED GARLIC CRUSTINI

SALADS

Available in half and full salad sizes

SPINACH (GF) 10.00: BABY SPINACH w/ WARM BACON ROASTED RED PEPPER ONION PORTOBELLO MUSHROOM VINAIGRETTE TOPPED w/ GRATED RICOTTA SALATA CHEESE
CAESAR 10.00: ROMAINE, HOUSEMADE CROUTONS, PARMESAN REGGIANO & PECORINO ROMANO CHEESES ADD EXTRA ANCHOVIES $3
RÚCULA (GF) 10.00: BABY ARUGULA, DRIED APRICOTS & FIGS, CRUMBLED GORGANZOLA CHEESE, TOASTED SLIVERED ALMONDS WHITE BALSAMIC VINAIGRETTE DRESSING
BEET (GF) 10.00: SLICED PICKLED BEETS & HAZELNUT CRUSTED SPANISH GOAT CHEESE over MIXED GREENS HONEY SHERRY VINAIGRETTE
THE GRECO (GF) 10.00: MIXED GREENS w/ GRAPE TOMATOES, CUCUMBERS, RED ONIONS, KALAMATA OLIVES, FETA CHEESE HERB VINAIGRETTE DRESSING

Dinner Menu

SHRIMP MENELAUS 29.00: WOOD FIRED OVEN BAKED SHRIMP w/ GARLIC, WHITE WINE & LEMON, TOPPED w/ FETA CHEESE & SEASONED BREAD CRUMBS w/ SAFFRON RICE
PROSCUITTO WRAP SALMON W/ CANNELLINI BEAN RAGOUT 32.00: PAN SEARED PROSCUITTO WRAPPPED SALMON OVER STEWED CANNELLINI BEANS, ESCAROLE, TOMATOES & ONIONS TOPPED w/ GARLIC - LEMON BUTTER & SAFFRON RICE (GF)
CAST IRON SKILLET BAKED COD (GF) 31.00: CHORIZO SAUSAGE, TOMATOES, BELL PEPPERS, LEEKS, GARLIC, WHITE WINE & GOAT CHEESE w/ SAFFRON RICE (Available without meat upon request)
CREAMY MUSHROOM & HERB RISOTTO WITH LUMP CRABMEAT 33.00: PAN ROASTED CREMINI MUSHROOMS, PORCINI MUSHROOM BROTH, CREAM & FRESH HERBS TOPPED w/TRUFFLE OIL & LUMP CRABMEAT
TUSCAN CHICKEN PASTA 27.00: GRILLED CHICKEN, SPINACH, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, PEAS, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, TOMATOES, CANNELINI BEANS, GARLIC & CHICKEN BROTH TOSSED w/ PENNE PASTA & TOPPED w/ MELTED FONTINA CHEESE
VEGETABLE NAPOLEAN (GF) 19.00: LAYERS OF HASH BROWN POTATOES, GRILLED PORTOBELLO MUSHROOMS, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, SAUTEED SPINACH & FRESH MOZZARELLA CHEESE w/ BALSAMIC GLAZE, POLENTA FRIES & BASIL PESTO AΪOLI
MOUSSAKA 23.00: WOOD FIRED OVEN BAKED GREEK SEASONED GROUND BEEF, PORK & VEAL LAYERED BETWEEN GRILLED EGGPLANT & SAUTEÉD POTATOES TOPPED w/ BECHAMEL SAUCE, GRATED PARMESAN CHEESE & NUTMEG
STEAK FRITES (GF) 33.00: GRILLED 8oz FLAT IRON SIRLOIN STEAK w/ BORDELAISE SAUCE, SAUTEÉD GREEN BEANS & HOUSE MADE PARMESAN SEASONED FRENCH FRIES
BRAISED BONELESS BEEF SHORT RIB OSSO BUCO (GF) 35.00: BRAISED BONELESS BEEF SHORT RIB OSSO BUCO (GF) BONELESS BEEF SHORT RIB BRAISED IN RED WINE, DEMI GLACE, TOMATOES, ONIONS, CELERY, CARROTS & GARLIC OVER TRUFFLE BUTTER MASHED POTATOES
GRILLED 8oz VEAL TENDERLOIN MARSALA (GF) 37.00: CREMINI MUSHROOMS, SHALLOTS, GARLIC, DEMI GLACE & MARSALA WINE w/ PANCETTA HOME FRIES
THREE 4oz GARLIC - ROSEMARY MARINATED GRILLED LAMB 33.00: w/ MAÎTRE d’ BUTTER, DEMI GLACE, SAUTEÉD GREEN BEANS & TRUFFLE BUTTER MASHED POTATOES
TOURNEDOS OF BEEF AU POIVRE (GF) 42.00: DUO OF CRACKED BLACK PEPPER CRUSTED 4oz BEEF TENDERLOIN FILETS BRANDY - SHALLOT - DIJON MUSTARD - DEMI GLACE CREAM SAUCE w/GARLIC SAUTEÉD SPINACH & TRUFFLED MASHED POTATOES

SIDES

PANCETTA & GARLIC PAN ROASTED PETITE BRUSSELS SPRO 8.00
CREAMY MUSHROOM & HERB RISOTTO (GF) 8.00
POLENTA FRIES w/ BASIL PESTO AIOLI (GF) 8.00
PARMESAN SEASONED HOUSE MADE FRENCH FRIES (GF) 8.00
PENNE PASTA 8.00: YOUR CHOICE OF EITHER MARINARA or BASIL PESTO ALFREDO SAUCES
TRUFFLE BUTTER MASHED POTATOES (GF) 8.00

BAR MENU

AVAILABLE IN DINING ROOM UPON REQUEST

SOUP DUJOUR 4.00: CUP
SOUP DUJOUR 8.00: BOWL
CHARCUTERIE PLATE 16.00: 12 MONTH AGED MANCHEGO, PECORINO ROMANO, FETA & BRIE CHEESES ASST CURED MEATS, MARINATED OLIVES w/ GRILLED GARLIC CRUSTINI
SAGANAKI (FLAMING CHEESE) 12.00: BREADED MELTED KASSERI CHEESE FLEMBÉ w/ WARM PITA BREAD
ARANCINI 12.00: ARBORIO RICE BALLS w/ SWEET FENNEL ITALIAN SAUSAGE, PEAS, MARINARA SAUCE & GRATED CHEESE (VEGETARIAN OPTION AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST $10)
TURKEY BURGER 17.00: GROUND TURKEY MIXED w/ SPINACH, ONIONS, DILL & FETA CHEESE ON A GRILLED CIABATTA ROLL w/ GRECO SALAD & TZATZIKI SAUCE
CALAMARI FRITO 17.00: LIGHTLY FRIED SQUID W/ LEMON – GARLIC AILOI & MARINARA SAUCE
GREEK STYLE CALAMARI 20.00: w/ KALAMATA OLIVES, PEPPERONCINI, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, FETA CHEESE, LEMON, WINE & GARLIC
VEGETARIAN MEATBALLS 11.00: ROASTED EGGPLANT, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, SUN DRIED TOMATO PESTO, GARLIC, BASIL, BREAD CRUMBS, PARMESAN & FETA CHEESES over MARINARA SAUCE
SHRIMP AJILLO (GF) 15.00: 3 SHRIMP SAUTEÉD IN OLIVE OIL w/ GARLIC, COGNAC, SMOKED PAPRIKA & LEMON over SAUTEÉD SPINACH
HOUSE MADE SAUSAGE SAMPLER 17.00: HOUSE MADE BLUEBERRY – CHIPOLTE & WINE – CHEESE – PARSLEY SAUSAGES GRILLED w/ DIJON MUSTARD, MARINATED OLIVES, CORNICHONE PICKLES, GARLIC MARINATED ROASTED RED PEPPERS w/ GRILLED GARLIC CRUSTINI
TAPAS SAMPLER 10.00: 1- ARINICINI 1- VEGETARIAN MEATBALL 1-SHRIMP AJILLO
WOOD FIRED OVEN PROSCIUTTO & FIG PIZZA 20.00: PROSCUITTO, DRIED FIGS, GORGANZOLA CHEESE & BALSAMIC GLAZE
WOOD FIRED OVEN VEGETARIAN GREEK PIZZA 18.00: ARTICHOKE HEARTS, KALAMATA OLIVES, ROASTED PEPPERS & FETA CHEESE TOPPED w/ WHITE BALSAMIC VINAIGRETE DRESSED BABY ARUGULA
WOOD OVEN FIRED PEPPERONI PIZZA 19.00: RED SAUCE, CUP and CHAR PEPPPERONI & MOZZARELLA
CHEESE PIZZA 14.00: RED SAUCE & MOZZARELLA
WOOD FIRED PEPPERONI, IT. SAUSAGE & 4 CHEESE PIZZA 21.00: RED SAUCE, PARMESAN REGGIANO, PECORINO ROMANO, MOZZARELLA & RICOTTA SALATA CHEESES

DESSERTS

HOUSE MADE

VANILLA BEAN CREME BRULEE (GF) 8.00: Caramelized Vanilla Custard Topped with Fresh Berries
BUTTERSCOTCH BUDINO (GF) 8.00: Butterscotch Custard with Salted Caramel Sauce & Chopped Almonds
FRIED ICE CREAM SPANISH SUNDAE 8.00: Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Coated with Vanilla Wafers, Cocoa, Chopped Spanish Peanuts & Corn Flakes Topped with Chocolate & Caramel Sauces, Whipped Cream & Spanish Peanuts
BAKLAVA A' LA MODE 8.00: Layers of Phyllo Dough, Walnuts, Honey & Cinnamon served with House Made Baklava Ice Cream
CHOCOLATE ESPRESSO POT DE CRE' ME (GF) 8.00: Dark Chocolate - Espresso Custard Topped with Whipped Cream, Chocolate Chips & Chocolate Espresso Beans
ICE CREAM "SANGAWICH” 8.00: House made Espresso - Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Between 2 Vanilla Pizzelle Spread with Nutella & Powdered Sugar
CANNOLI 4.00: lmpasata Ricotta Cheese. Vanilla, Cinnamon & Chocolate Chips
DESSERT SAMPLER 14.00: (2 Pieces of each) Baklava, Chocolate-Espresso Pot De Crème, Almond Short Bread Cookies, Mini Cannoli's
AFFOGATO al CAFFÈ 8.00: Scoop of Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Topped with Fresh Brewed Hot Espresso * Choice of Regular or Decaffeinated
SORBET SAMPLER (GF/LF) 7.00: Ask your server for available flavors

Customer Reviews & Ratings

4.82 out of 5 stars based on 3556 votes

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 24, 2025

Sharon R.

Everything was great! Food and service made our evening special!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 17, 2025

Traci K.

From the ease of reserving online to the wonderful happy hostess to the perfect waiter and the sweet and attentive support staff it was a great value for the money.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 9/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 17, 2025

James P.

Great energy, comfortable setting and excellent service. Food is also wonderful. We keep coming back.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Apr 15, 2025

Angie C.

We loved the ambiance, the service was exceptional and our meals were very well prepared and presented. We will be back!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 13, 2025

Dr Robert F.

We discovered Polizzi’s many years ago due to its proximity to the RBTL shows. We decided to try dinner there as it was one of very few restaurants that had “saganaki!” OPAH! What we discovered, was a lovely restaurant gem with a wonderful menu! Chef Tom features a mix of Greek, Novo, American, Italian and seasonal specials. All delicious and wonderfully prepared on any given night, he features some new fish dish on his menu every day. The restaurant also features its own homemade bread and soups to die for. My wife and I find the restaurant warm and welcoming with a very caring staff. It has become one of our “Go To Restaurants!”

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 12, 2025

Frank T.

Love it there! The food is great and the people are so nice ❤️

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 10, 2025

Paul H.

This was our second time here, and the food was excellent again. perfect whiskey, sour and margarita. Our son, the vegetarian, enjoyed the meatballs and the beet salad a little pricey, but worth it.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 03, 2025

Jim C.

Service was wonderful. Food was spectacular. We brought some friends from out of town and they just loved everything.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 31, 2025

Sue F.

Always a great experience; food and value are excellent!!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 28, 2025

Lois H.

Great food! Great service!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 13, 2025

Kelly S.

Excellent! Joe our server was wonderful. Food is outstanding and the restaurant is comfortable and has a great energy. Love the short ribs!!! Polizzi’s is a Jewel in Rochester. Thank you!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 28, 2025

MaryAnn T.

The experience was very nice. Food was excellent. Best food we had in a very long time.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 27, 2025

Philip P.

Had a wonderful dinner with another couple prior to an RBTL show. Everything was outstanding! The menu options, the appetizers and meals, the service … all top notch. We will be back!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 27, 2025

Terri O.

Really enjoyed my first visit! All was great, including a very clean restroom :-) I'll be back for another meal soon.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 13, 2025

Hutch H.

Always great food and service. My go-to place for a great meal!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 18, 2025

Penny B.

We had a wonderful time. The food and service were great. It was our first time at this restaurant and we will be back. We enjoyed the Wednesday night special menu along with appetizers and a dessert. Everyone only had good things to say about the dinner.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 18, 2025

Cathy A.

Each time we’ve dined here, we can’t be more happy with the experience. My husband usually gets the bacon wrapped salmon. I tried the veggie napoleon for a change. A super meal.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 07, 2025

Billy G.

This was the third time we have eaten here. Great service and exceptional food every time. Highly recommend Polizzis!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 03, 2025

Gina D.

We went there for a family meal and enjoyed all of our food. Everything was superb!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 01, 2025

Shawn B.

Another wonderful experience at Polizzi’s!! Chef Tom is amazing!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 10, 2024

Linda R.

It was a little noisy/loud, just a little more so than normal. I think maybe the sound carried a little. We all enjoyed a great meal, great service, and will return again!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 10, 2024

Paula D.

We enjoyed our dinner at Polizzi’s immensely. The restaurant was decorated very tastefully for the holidays making the environment festive. Our server, Eileen, was excellent and the food was delicious. I would and have recommended Polizzi’s to others.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 06, 2024

Jeanne A.

Everything from making the reservation, then changing the time, to the food was perfect! We will be back!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 30, 2024

Vicki C.

We love Polizzi’s. Everything about it is marvelous. The menu is very inventive.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 9/10; Value: 9/10

Nov 27, 2024

Irene P.

The only “complaint “ that I had was about the homemade mozzarella sticks. They were delicious but a couple didn’t really have much cheese in them. It must have leaked out during the frying process and I know that this can easily happen.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 9/10; Value: 9/10

Nov 24, 2024

Tony C.

The appetizer eggplant meatballs were excellent. The waitress let us sample a few draft beers on tap which was very helpful. My pork chop was a 10 but my wife’s fish was maybe a 7. It was a little dry and only okay tasting.We have eaten often and it was our first disappointing entree. We will be back! Lovely restaurant!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 24, 2024

Derek H.

First time here…definitely not the last!!! Everything was GREAT. Food selection is amazing and the quality is even better. We started with the Greek calamari and flaming saganaki. I had vegetarian meatballs and the arugula salad; my husband had prosciutto wrapped salmon. Tiramisu and crème brûlée for dessert. All first rate! We can’t wait to go back to try some of their other offerings which looked wonderful. Service is top notch and friendly. The staff work as a team and made us feel special. Nicely done Polozzi’s. You have made friends for life.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 23, 2024

Michael C.

From start to finish the staff was attentive to our table, food was very good.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 16, 2024

Jennifer J.

First, I loved the cream of mushroom soup!!! It was addicting. My mushroom risotto with lump crab meat hit the spot and was creamy and so tasty. This was the 2nd time I’ve been there at plan on going back.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 11, 2024

Al R.

Food was outstanding. Staff was accommodating and pleasant. Overall a very good experience.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 10, 2024

Ace R.

Really nice restaurant

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Oct 21, 2024

Marycarla H.

Absolutely WONDERFUL from start to finish! Erica is amazing! Second time we have been there and both times she has been our server. TOP NOTCH! We will return! Have taken two different sets of out-of-town guests and everyone has raved about the service and the food. We will definitely be returning alone and with guests!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Oct 17, 2024

Richard D.

The team at Polizzi's does a great job from making you feel welcome to serving excellent food. Thanks.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Oct 16, 2024

Jordan P.

Drinks and food was fantastic! Our server was very sweet and very knowledgeable about the menu. We will definitely be back!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Oct 12, 2024

Elsbeth C.

The food, people,and the ambience are always top notch

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Oct 03, 2024

Michele B.

Lovely place. Staff was excellent! Food was delicious

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 9/10; Value: 9/10

Oct 01, 2024

Ronny F.

Meal was delicious!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Sep 28, 2024

Brooke N.

A perfect dinner!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Sep 28, 2024

Vicki E.

Food and service was great

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 7/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Sep 22, 2024

Ann C.

Service & food were excellent!! Will definitely return & recommend

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Sep 18, 2024

Kathy K.

Wonderful service

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Sep 16, 2024

Dana C.

Wonderful! Looking forward to returning, as always!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Sep 12, 2024

Terry D.

The salmon with bacon over cannellini beans was so fantastic I almost went back the next night. I recommend this place unqualifiedly. And our waiter was cheerful and enthusiastic. Our best meal in Rochester.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Sep 03, 2024

Alan G.

Pleasant and attentive staff. Always top notch service and fresh, tasty food. I highly recommend Polizzi's.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Aug 29, 2024

Gene C.

Always great, best food in town!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Aug 20, 2024

Sue F.

Always my favorite go-to for a night out!!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Jul 27, 2024

Lois Z.

A delicious meal

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jul 15, 2024

Julie A.

Everything was top notch! The staff is friendly and accommodating and the food was perfectly prepared and very delicious. Dining outside feels like being at an Italian bistro. Polizzi’s is one of our favorite restaurants!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jul 12, 2024

HELEN E.

Food and service was excellent. It was a great night to sit outside on their patio!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 26, 2024

Laura D.

Fantastic food and service!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 23, 2024

Lori H.

Food and service was excellent. Seated on time, no waiting. Explained specials in detail.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 21, 2024

Jeanne R.

The service is always good, the food is always consistently hot and delicious. A favorite place to eat always!!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 14, 2024

Ann Marie D.

Our waitress last evening was awesome. Patient, friendly, informative. She had a tattoo of a flame on her arm—a concealed fire arm. Brilliant! She made the evening and dinner even more enjoyable sitting on your patio!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 08, 2024

Sue T.

We love eating at Polizzis. We can always count on gourmet food and great service. Polizzis never disappoints!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 07, 2024

Pam C.

ALWAYS have a great meal and great service!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 04, 2024

Shelene H.

Our 2nd time there, Angie was our super attentive and informative server. We will definitely be back when we are in the city again, or make the trip up. Love the location and everyone there is so friendly.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 8/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 03, 2024

Kecia B.

Dinner was lovely and amazing as always. So delicious!!! We were celebrating, and indicated so on our reservation yet no mention of it was made by any staff during our time dining. Just an acknowledgement would have been a special touch added to our experience. Why ask on the reservation form if you don’t bother to acknowledge it?

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 10/10

May 21, 2024

Arthur C.

The only thing I would change is the noise level. It was very hard to carry a conversation at our table.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

May 19, 2024

Carol S.

We loved it and will be back soon!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 10/10

May 13, 2024

Ellen R.

A little noisy.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

May 09, 2024

Mary W.

Very professional, friendly staff and the food was delicious. (Try the blueberry sausage!) Also love NOTA- its great part of Rochester.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

May 06, 2024

Lydia S.

Everything was great! Service was friendly and prompt

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 9/10; Value: 10/10

May 06, 2024

Denise B.

Love Polizzis! The food is outstanding and somehow Tom keeps the price reasonable!! Great service with sa friendly staff. Just a little noisy at times..

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 9/10; Value: 9/10

May 04, 2024

Kimberly P.

An excellent experience as always! I was happy to bring a newbie with me last night - she was very comfortable and happy. Joe provided professional and friendly service as I've come to expect. Will be back for Italian American nights in the future!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

May 03, 2024

LISA M.

My first time there and will definitely go back!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 22, 2024

Bonnie Z.

Everything was perfect!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 18, 2024

Tina G.

Amazing! The food and staff were great.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 17, 2024

Michele R.

We had an amazing dinner and our waiter, Joe, was exceptional!!! The vegetable Napoleon was delicious! Can’t wait to go back.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 7/10; Value: 9/10

Apr 09, 2024

Patti C.

Everything was great except I was there for a special occasion right as they opened and we were seated in the bar area instead of the dining area which was EMPTY and it was not full our entire stay.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 09, 2024

Sue F.

Never disappoints!!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 05, 2024

Charles R.

Great experience!!!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 05, 2024

Shawn B.

Great atmosphere, great food, great service and chef Tom is amazing!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 31, 2024

Gino S.

Had an awesome meal with a friendly, attentive staff.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 30, 2024

Jeanne M.

Delicious food and great service.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 27, 2024

Tammy D.

It was absolutely fantastic. we had a group of 13. our server was amazing!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 9/10

Mar 24, 2024

Nick D.

This was one of the best dining experiences we have had in Rochester. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, and the price for the value was great. We'll definitely be returning and adding Polizzi's to our list of favorite restaurants.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 10, 2024

Steven R.

10 across the board! First tome there and now one of my Favorite restaurants! We Sat at the bar and got a chance to meet and talk with the bar tender. He’s awesome. We will be back!!!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 01, 2024

Alexis A.

Excellent food, lovely staff, very good service. Since August, when we came to RIT from France, we have already been 4 times. Never disappointed. Try the saganaki and then the baklava as dessert and you will immediately agree

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 23, 2024

Stephen C.

Everyone in my party of 8 enjoyed our experience at Polizzi's. The food was excellent and the service top notch. We will be back and I'll be certain to share my review with friends.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 22, 2024

Dave F.

Wonderful food, great, patient friendly waitress. Excellent evening

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 17, 2024

Milli P.

I'm a semi regular and LOVE Polizzi's–kudos to the owner for the high standards he has established and kusos to the always professional and proficient staff,.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 05, 2024

Barbara G.

Polizzi's is our go to place on theater night! We have tried several restaurants in the area, but Polizzi's is consistently top notch in food, service and atmosphere!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 05, 2024

Connie Z.

Wonderful evening!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 03, 2024

Tracy M.

We had a blast as we always do when we go! Katie our server was fabulous!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 8/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 03, 2024

Mary S.

Had a great dinner before a show.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 30, 2024

Thomas B.

Our favorite restaurant. Food is always outstanding. Our waiter Brian is the best, he is also an excellent bartender. Can’t wait to return.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 9/10

Jan 30, 2024

Christopher R.

Had a very nice time with delicious food and drinks.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 17, 2024

Barbara W.

I hadn’t even heard of this restaurant until recently. Will definitely be coming back! From the young woman who took us to our table, to our server, and the chef’s masterpieces, everything was wonderful! Even the young girl who boxed up our leftovers was amazing. And she labeled everything, besides. ❤️

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 13, 2024

Mike S.

The food and service were better than 10 off the charts

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 09, 2024

Kurt J.

Food was excellent -- so much so that the next morning I woke up sad that I hadn't sent a message to thank the chef! I had lamb with mashed potatoes and green beans, and even though I was "too full" for dessert, ate almost half of my husband's creme brulee which was another masterpiece.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 06, 2024

James P.

Great food, fair prices, good service, always enjoyable.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 02, 2024

Jean M.

Wonderful experience and delicious food.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 25, 2023

Kathy T.

Our family had such an enjoyable time celebrating the Christmas season with a delicious meal together. We all raved about the food, and were treated with great service. Thank you for such a great time.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 17, 2023

Lisa M.

We dine at Polizzi's often - love the food, staff, chef, all of it!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 13, 2023

Martha D.

Noisy but was pretty full.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 06, 2023

Denise B.

Always have a fabulous meal at Polizzis! Wait staff is outstanding!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 01, 2023

Charles R.

My family and I had a wonderful experience at your restaurant this past Wednesday! Kelly our waitress was personable but not intrusive. She addended to our needs even before we made requests. My wife and I were touched that Kelly related to our developmentally delayed daughter with grace and compassion. She even took time out of her busy schedule to take our picture.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 01, 2023

Maggie K.

Polizzi's is our go-to for special occasions. Service by adult professionals, diverse menu expertly prepared, good bar/wine list selections. We have never been disappointed with the food, the service, or the price. It's the best Rochester has to offer in fine dining in our opinion.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 1/10; Ambience: 9/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 28, 2023

Mark O.

Very pleasant evening and a great dinner.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 20, 2023

Marilyn M.

Excellent food, atmosphere and service. Waitress Angie was wonderful!

Polizzi's

Reservations

Polizzi's Reservations

A special access code is required for this event. Please enter your access code.

Business Info

Photos

Business Hours

Reservations Available

F.A.Q.s

Menus

Dinner Menu

Appitizers

SALADS

Dinner Menu

SIDES

BAR MENU

DESSERTS

Customer Reviews & Ratings

4.82 out of 5 stars based on 3556 votes

Sharon R.

Traci K.

James P.

Angie C.

Dr Robert F.

Frank T.

Paul H.

Jim C.

Sue F.

Lois H.

Kelly S.

MaryAnn T.

Philip P.

Terri O.

Hutch H.

Penny B.

Cathy A.

Billy G.

Gina D.

Shawn B.

Linda R.

Paula D.

Jeanne A.

Vicki C.

Irene P.

Tony C.

Derek H.

Michael C.

Jennifer J.

Al R.

Ace R.

Marycarla H.

Richard D.

Jordan P.

Elsbeth C.

Michele B.

Ronny F.

Brooke N.

Vicki E.

Ann C.

Kathy K.

Dana C.

Terry D.

Alan G.

Gene C.

Sue F.

Lois Z.

Julie A.

HELEN E.

Laura D.

Lori H.

Jeanne R.

Ann Marie D.

Sue T.

Pam C.

Shelene H.

Kecia B.

Arthur C.

Carol S.

Ellen R.

Mary W.