Sugar Mill Restaurant

Apple Bay, Tortola 0300

$$$$ International Recommended Editor's Pick Private Room View Outdoor Seating

The Sugar Mill - a fine dining restaurant featuring fresh lobsters, the best steak in our "Steak Bar," Tournedos Rossini, Scallops in champagne sauce, pate de foie gras, escargots, gourmet risottos, duck, chicken curry and roulade, white fish as well as vegetarian and Caribbean specialties. Open six nights a week for dinner - [ closed Wednesdays in the summer season after April 1st ] from 7.00 pm. Breakfast from Mon - Saturday 8.00 - 10.00 am.

Reservations

Sugar Mill Restaurant Reservations

1-284-3448612

Date

Time

Party Size

Business Info

Address: Apple Bay, Tortola 0300
Cross Street: Rte 1
Cuisine: American | French | International | Seafood | Steak | Vegetarian |
Cost: | Expensive
Category: Fine Dining
Star Rating:
Reservations: Recommended
Dress Code: Casual Elegant
Meals Served: Breakfast | Dinner |
Parking: Car Park |
Payment Options: VISA | Amex | MasterCard |
Corkage Fee: N/A
Website: http://www.sugarmillhotel.com/
Phone: 1-284-3448612
Features: Winning Wine List,
Occasion: Romantic Dining, Business Dining, Celebrity Spotting,

Photos

Sugar Mill Restaurant - Sugar Mill Restaurant

Business Hours

Reservations Available

Monday: Dinner - Terrace 6 p.m. - 10 p.m.
Tuesday: Dinner - Terrace 6 p.m. - 10 p.m.
Wednesday: Dinner - Terrace 6 p.m. - 9:30 p.m.
Thursday: Dinner - Terrace 6 p.m. - 10 p.m.
Friday: Dinner - Terrace 6 p.m. - 10 p.m.
Saturday: Dinner - Terrace 6 p.m. - 10 p.m.
Sunday: Dinner - Terrace 6 p.m. - 10 p.m.

False

Customer Reviews & Ratings

4.75 out of 5 stars based on 341 votes

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 22, 2023

Wil M.

enjoyed everything with the exception of road traffic.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 20, 2023

Scott K.

Exceptional

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 08, 2023

David S.

Fabulous!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 04, 2023

Christina E.

Excellent food, service and ambience. One of my favorite dining experiences on Tortola.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 27, 2023

Keith L.

Wait staff should top off wine when asking how our meal was. We had a wonderful evening, food wonderful, staff a delight and a lovely chat with the hosts.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 23, 2023

Kim R.

This was the first time dining at the Sugar Mill Restaurant, and we already made another reservation to come back! Service was excellent, the owner is lovely and very attentive. The drinks and food were delicious and the birthday cake that they made specific for our party was amazing, probably one of the tastiest cakes we have ever had. Thank you Sugar Mill for making our night a memorable one. See you soon

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 02, 2023

Debra M.

Lovely, beautiful atmosphere. Food was great and came in timely manner. Would definitely go back again.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Dec 31, 2022

Kristen W.

Great place, would recommend and go back again! Food was amazing!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 7/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 7/10

Dec 27, 2022

Janine T.

Beautiful place with great food. Best restaurant we found in Tortola.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 12, 2022

Angelina P.

Great place

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Oct 20, 2022

Danielle L.

We had a great time

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Oct 20, 2022

Dion S.

Great Food that always exceeds your expectations

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 7/10

Jul 22, 2022

Smith T.

Everything was great we both enjoyed it!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jun 16, 2022

Christopher C.

Food was excellent, staff attentive and wine was excellent

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Apr 16, 2022

Amber G.

Best meal on the BVI! Beautiful ambience and amazing food/service

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 22, 2022

Alicia C.

We loved everything about this hotel and restaurant! Magical place!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Mar 09, 2022

Sara S.

Lovely Restaurant and we will be back for sure!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 08, 2022

Anthony W.

Excellent all round. Hooray ! Food for foodies. Couldn't find anywhere on East side / Road Town to come anywhere close.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 03, 2022

Peter S.

Great food, great service, great ambiance

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Feb 25, 2022

Anne M.

Fabulous spot. Total gem.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Feb 03, 2022

Joseph G.

Beautiful restaurant. Wonderful people. Good Food. Paradise doesn’t come cheap

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 9/10

Jan 27, 2022

Sergio D.

Great experience as usual! No wonder is our favourite restaurant on island!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 9/10

Jan 14, 2022

Mike W.

We had a very nice dinner. The food was excellent. The service was very good.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 14, 2022

Michael A.

Repeat customers, a

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 0/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 22, 2021

Greg L.

Looking forward to more visits .

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 20, 2021

Robert hotel guests B.

The Sugar Mill Restaraunt remains excellent! The service was attentive but not rushed. The lobster was delicious. The setting on the Terrace was beautiful and felt just like dining in the Sugar Mill room used to feel but with ocean sounds. We also stayed in the hotel which was perfect and we were able to have a wonderful breakfast as well. Could not recommend higher. You should eat here.

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 17, 2021

Harold C.

The fish dish we had was excellent

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Dec 15, 2021

Loleta S.

Great service enjoy it .

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Nov 18, 2021

Valerie C.

We LOVE the Sugar Mill! The food was amazing!

: Overall: 10/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Mar 12, 2021

Chenae W.

We were really in love with the tenderness of the chicken. Love it

: Overall: 9/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 5/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 10/10

Jan 06, 2023

107 Emily/Ian W.

Great food, amazing location, friendly service, but a bit slower than you might expect in a city. Overall lovely evening.

: Overall: 9/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 6/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 9/10

Nov 03, 2022

Michele L.

We loved the food but it would be really lovely if the menu could indicate allergies ie gluten free, vegan etc and some alternatives be available thank you

: Overall: 9/10; Food: 8/10; Service: 9/10; Ambience: 9/10; Value: 8/10

Oct 21, 2022

Charlotte C.

Lovely wait staff who make you feel genuinely welcome. The menu at Sugar Mill is classic French, very traditional but nothing wrong with that as long as you enjoy butter and cream (which we do). I eat here regularly and it is consistently good. I like the wide selection of "house" wines which are reasonably priced at $37 per bottle (a very low mark-up on local retail prices) and the more luxury selection is very nicely curated, with some real gems to enjoy.

: Overall: 9/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 9/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 9/10

Oct 21, 2022

Susan F.

Enjoyed the entire experience! The decor and ambiance was very tasteful. Very happy and gracious staff. Large menu selections of both food and wine. Background music was delightful. Would highly recommend!

: Overall: 9/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 9/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 9/10

Dec 27, 2021

Alan L.

Good was excellent, Christmas pudding definitely packed a punch! Staff were extremely friendly, and a beautiful venue for a Christmas dinner

: Overall: 8/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 5/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Mar 02, 2023

linda G.

Beautifully arranged, food was good, my lobster was overcooked. Servicer was very friendly, but service was very slow coming from the bar & kitchen. I’m sure it has to do with employee issues. Def will be back

: Overall: 8/10; Food: 8/10; Service: 7/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Feb 12, 2023

Tracey G.

our party of 4 enjoyed 2 dinners at Sugar Mill and table location makes a difference. the first dinner our table was on the first tier near the bar was lovely. second dinner 2/9 we were the last table at the rear of restaurant. okay but there was quite a disturbance in the kitchen between staff, the manager had to intervene several times. it caused uneven service and was distracting. 2 dinners arrived and there was a fairly long wait for the remaining 2 meals to be delivered. also fine dining we expect the server to know who ordered what - not asking who gets the fish pie??

: Overall: 8/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 10/10; Ambience: 6/10; Value: 8/10

Jan 03, 2023

Susan O.

Always love the sugar mill. However, this time we had a really awful table. Since we had made our reservation almost 6 months ago i would have thought we would have been in a better location. That being said, Marilyn was a fantastic server and the music was excellent.

: Overall: 8/10; Food: 10/10; Service: 2/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 8/10

Dec 30, 2022

Kate M.

The manager is amazing and the owner wonderful but the staff couldn't offer proper service, waited over an hour for drinks and had to ask. Not everyone got the same menu. Had to ask for drinks multiple times and they would bring out one plate at a time. We had 3 kids with us who were pretty hungry but everything took so long that we had to break the party up and send some kids home and take to go boxes. The owner organised all of that for us which was wonderful because the staff weren't doing it.

: Overall: 8/10; Food: 6/10; Service: 9/10; Ambience: 8/10; Value: 4/10

Jul 02, 2022

Julie H.

This was a difficult review to make because the service was wonderful and everyone else’s food was amazing; however, as a vegetarian, it wasn’t! Risotto was the only vegetarian option and I chose the caprese one. The olives were the cheap ones I never buy and I don’t actually think fresh basil was used, and instead, they used dried. All I can say is it wasn’t very nice at all. When you consider I was charged $25 for the basic risotto and then another $10 for the mozzarella, basil and olives, I was not impressed! Everyone else’s food looked great and was thoroughly enjoyed but as a vegetarian, I am fed up being offered very little choice and the quality being poor.

: Overall: 8/10; Food: 9/10; Service: 9/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 9/10

Feb 26, 2022

Robert C.

The only hiccup was a special escargot plate was dropped on a lady guest with remaining butter hitting her dress. She was nice about it, but no accommodation was made to credit the plate or anything.

: Overall: 8/10; Food: 8/10; Service: 7/10; Ambience: 10/10; Value: 9/10